The Commons

…colleges and universities are advertising so lavishly in The Chronicle of Higher Education.  It’s a trend that’s been accelerating lately, and it’s really getting out of hand.  In the March 12, 2010 edition there are full-page ads by:

•    University of North Texas
•    Arcadia University
•    East Carolina University
•    Texas A&M (three pages worth! And they’ve been doing it for months.)

On top of that, this issue includes smaller ads by San Francisco State University, Western New England College, University of Houston, University of Scranton, University of South Florida, Vanderbilt (Peabody College), Metropolitan State College of Denver, and others.

What gives?

I know that the Chronicle is the paper of record in academe—no dispute there.  But the great majority of eyeballs that these institutions are buying with these image ads have nothing to do with the products or services that the ads purport to be selling.  What difference does it make that the academics who make up the bulk of Chronicle readership know the touching life story of a Bolivian student at UNT?  Why would these readers care about the new accelerated three-year baccalaureate program at Arcadia?  What new service would these readers be expected to buy from Texas A&M based on three pages of ads extolling their research contributions?

Even more puzzling is that some of the ads seem to be geared to the student recruitment market, and if I know anything about the teen reader, I know that they are not reading the Chronicle, unless it’s available by text and IM.

The only rationale I can gin up for these ads is that they are an attempt to influence the voters in the U.S. News and other rankings—but at nearly $16,000 a pop for a full-page, four-color ad, I’m not sure it’s money well spent.  Quick calculations suggest that Texas A&M has spent somewhere between $250,000-$300,000 this year alone on these ads, and we’re not even to the end of the first quarter.  Now, as a marketing guy, I am of course in favor of advertising: it’s one of the only ways you can get your message out in a way that you completely control.  But good advertising is about targeting—configuring your buy in such a fashion as to make sure that you’re able to reach your target audience with a message that will cause them to do what you want them to do.  But some of these ads just seem to me to miss the mark—or at least to aim at a mark that I don’t understand.

If I’m missing something, fill me in.

- Rob Moore, Managing Partner

Tags: advertising, brand personality, Chronicle of Higher Education, higher education, lipman hearne, media strategy, nonprofit branding, nonprofit marketing, resources, targeting, trends